Emotional and Physical Affairs: How Researchers Tell Them Apart

emotional affair vs physical affair

If you’re weighing an emotional affair vs physical affair, the short answer is in how researchers define them. Sexual infidelity means sex without love; emotional infidelity means falling in love without sex.

You can find the wider data in our infidelity statistics guide.

Item Value
Heterosexual men most upset by sexual infidelity 54 percent
Heterosexual women most upset by sexual infidelity 35 percent
Heterosexual men most upset by emotional infidelity 46 percent
Heterosexual women most upset by emotional infidelity 65 percent
Survey size 63,894 participants, ages 18-65
Extramarital sexual activity in a meta-analysis of 50 studies 34 percent of men, 24 percent of women

These figures come from a Chapman University survey described in its January 2015 release and the ScienceDaily summary. Figures can change as new research appears, so check the source before you rely on them.

How researchers define an emotional affair and a physical one

In the Chapman University study, sexual infidelity was defined as having sex outside the relationship without emotional attachment, while emotional infidelity meant “falling in love” with someone outside the relationship without having sex (Chapman blog summary). Those clean categories are a research tool.

Real situations are messier, and where your own line sits is a separate question. A closer look at what counts as infidelity can help you frame it.

To compare the two, the survey asked participants to imagine a forced choice between:

  • their partner having sex with someone else, but not falling in love with them; or
  • their partner falling in love with someone else, but not having sex with them.

Each person then said which scenario would upset them more.

What the largest survey found

As of the university’s January 2015 release, the poll was described as the largest study to date on infidelity. It covered 63,894 Americans ages 18-65, who were in their late 30s on average. The researchers noted that most earlier work relied on small samples or college samples.

Among heterosexual adults, the answers split along gender lines:

  • Men: 54 percent were most upset by sexual infidelity and 46 percent by emotional infidelity.
  • Women: 35 percent were most upset by sexual infidelity and 65 percent by emotional infidelity.

Because each person had to pick one scenario, the two figures for each group mirror each other. The results appeared in the journal Archives of Sexual Behavior, listed by ScienceDaily as a 2014 paper.

emotional affair vs physical affair Outdoor conversation
Two women face each other across an outdoor table.

The lead author said heterosexual men “really stand out from all other groups”: they were the only group much more likely to be most upset by sexual rather than emotional infidelity. The release also cited a review of ethnographic accounts from 16 societies, which found infidelity was the most common cause of marital dissolution.

Why do men and women react differently?

The release describes an evolutionary perspective. Men face paternal uncertainty, because they can never be sure a child is genetically theirs, so heightened sexual jealousy is expected. Women do not face maternal uncertainty, but they risk losing resources and commitment if a partner invests in another mate.

A sociocultural reading points the other way at first, since it generally expects no difference between men and women. The study notes, though, that men are socialized to prize sexual prowess, so a partner’s sexual infidelity can threaten their masculinity. Women are taught to think relationally and be emotional nurturers, so emotional infidelity may threaten their sense of self more.

The researchers also said a person’s reaction is likely shaped by environmental and personal factors, not by gender alone.

How attachment style changes the picture

A 2010 report on research in the journal Psychological Science questioned the prevailing evolutionary explanation. Pennsylvania State University scientists noticed a conspicuous subset of men who, like most women, find emotional betrayal more distressing than sexual infidelity. The new study did not question the gender difference; it added support for it while offering another layer.

The scientists looked at attachment style, meaning how secure or self-reliant people are in close relationships:

  • People with a dismissing attachment style, who prize autonomy over commitment, were much more upset about sexual infidelity than emotional infidelity.
  • People who were securely attached, including securely attached men, were much more likely to find emotional betrayal more upsetting.

The report suggests that promoting secure attachment may be an effective way to reduce the kind of sexual jealousy that contributes to domestic violence. That is a suggestion from the researchers, not a proven remedy.

Sexual orientation, age and other factors

The Chapman survey also looked beyond heterosexual adults. Its findings on other groups and background factors were:

  • Bisexual men and women did not differ significantly.
  • Gay men and lesbian women also did not differ.
  • Age, income and whether people had children were unrelated to which type of infidelity upset them more.
  • Younger participants were notably more upset by sexual infidelity than older participants.

The gender difference among heterosexual adults emerged across age groups, income levels, history of being cheated on, history of being unfaithful, relationship type and relationship length. The lead author added that the attitudes of gay, lesbian and bisexual people have been historically understudied in psychology.

What this research can and cannot tell you

The survey measured imagined upset, not what happens inside real affairs. It also does not tell you how common emotional affairs are; the sources used here give no such figure. The only prevalence number in them is a meta-analysis of 50 studies, which found that 34 percent of men and 24 percent of women have engaged in extramarital sexual activities.

Both types can do damage. The Chapman release lists harms that can follow either kind:

  • broken hearts and relationships ending abruptly and painfully;
  • abandonment;
  • partner violence;
  • loss of resources when they are invested in affair partners.

Why people step outside a relationship in the first place is a different question from how a partner reacts, and a look at why do people cheat takes up that side of it.

Frequently asked questions

Which hurts more, an emotional affair or a physical one?

Show answer

It depends on the person. In the Chapman survey, 65 percent of heterosexual women and 46 percent of heterosexual men were most upset by emotional infidelity, while 54 percent of heterosexual men and 35 percent of heterosexual women were most upset by sexual infidelity.

How do researchers define an emotional affair?

Show answer

In the Chapman study, emotional infidelity meant “falling in love” with someone outside the relationship without having sex. Other researchers or couples may draw the line differently.

Does gender fully explain who is more upset by which?

Show answer

No. The research on attachment found that people with a dismissing attachment style were much more upset by sexual infidelity, while securely attached people, including men, were more upset by emotional betrayal.

Do gay, lesbian and bisexual people react the same way?

Show answer

In the Chapman survey, bisexual men and women did not differ significantly, and gay men and lesbian women also did not differ. Heterosexual men were the only group much more likely to be most upset by sexual infidelity.

How common is infidelity?

Show answer

One meta-analysis of 50 studies, cited in the Chapman release, found that 34 percent of men and 24 percent of women have engaged in extramarital sexual activities. The release adds that infidelity in dating relationships is even higher, and the sources give no figure for emotional affairs alone.