If you and your partner disagree about what counts as infidelity, you’re not unusual. Physical acts are widely counted; online and emotional behaviors split opinion, so the safest line is the one you agree on together.
For the wider numbers behind this topic, see our infidelity statistics overview.
| Item | Value |
|---|---|
| Participants in a 2010 thesis survey on defining infidelity | 967 people |
| Behaviors rated in that survey | 21 |
| Americans calling a one-night stand “always cheating” (2017 poll) | 73 percent |
| Americans calling flirtatious messages “always cheating” | 51 percent |
| Americans calling following an ex on social media “always cheating” | 16 percent |
| Calling an online dating profile “always cheating” | 70 percent of women, 55 percent of men |
The figures come from a 2010 master’s thesis and a 2017 Deseret News/YouGov poll report. Survey results can change as attitudes shift, so check the source before you rely on them.
Where most people agree: physical contact
Ask people about sex or kissing outside the relationship and the answers are close to unanimous. In the 2017 Deseret News poll, roughly three quarters of Americans said that having sex or kissing someone other than your partner is always cheating.
The poll was run by Y2 Analytics and YouGov from March 17-19, 2017. It covered 1,000 U.S. adults and has a margin of error of 3.1 percent.
Two of the physical items stood out:
- Regular sexual relations with someone other than your partner: 76 percent said this is always cheating.
- A one-night stand with someone other than your partner: 73 percent said the same.
The 2010 thesis points the same way. Its author found no differences by gender with regard to physical or sexual infidelity, even though other categories showed gaps.
Why online behavior is a gray area
Agreement thins quickly once the behavior moves online. In the same poll, 51 percent said sending flirtatious messages is always cheating, 19 percent said so about watching pornography without a partner, and 16 percent said so about following an ex on social media. In each of those cases, at least 25 percent said the activity sometimes counts as cheating, according to the poll report.
The “sometimes” answers show how much depends on context:
- Following an ex on social media: 45 percent said it is sometimes cheating.
- Sending flirtatious messages to someone who isn’t your partner: 31 percent said it is sometimes a problem.
- Watching pornography without your partner: 28 percent said it is sometimes a problem.
A psychologist quoted in the report explained why internet cheating is so common: “It’s accessible, especially with a smartphone.” A therapist and professor quoted there said new technologies create a gray area that couples can struggle to navigate together.

The same therapist added a point that holds on or off a screen: “Whether it’s offline or online, betrayal is betrayal.” In other words, the medium may be ambiguous even when the hurt is not.
Do men and women define infidelity differently?
Partly, but the gap is smaller than many people assume. The 2017 poll found women more likely than men to define 11 behaviors as cheating. The gap was largest for internet-enabled activity: 70 percent of women but only 55 percent of men said maintaining an online dating profile is always cheating, per the Deseret News report.
The 2010 thesis offers a more detailed picture. In its online survey, participants were given a list of 21 behaviors across three categories: sexual contact, online interaction, and emotional/romantic interaction. Overall, women classified more online and emotional behaviors as infidelity than men did.
But in an item-by-item analysis, 15 items showed no difference by gender. The four emotional items and two online items that did differ showed small effect sizes. Our guide to emotional affair vs physical affair compares those two categories in more detail.
How age, faith and relationship status shift the line
Gender is only one factor. The poll found that millennials were generally less strict than their elders, and that opinions differed significantly among members of different faiths.
The thesis found smaller effects from two personal factors:
- Sexual orientation had a small effect on both emotional and online infidelity identification.
- Relationship status had a small effect on the number of items identified as emotional and online infidelity.
The thesis author concluded that many online and emotional behaviors lack a clear consensus as to whether they count as infidelity. That is useful for clinicians, and it is just as useful for couples. If a claim about who defines cheating how sounds too tidy, compare it with the common infidelity myths and what the evidence says.
How to set your own definition together
Because the public has no single answer, the practical move is to make your own. The steps below are a suggested way to start the conversation, not a clinical protocol.
- Each of you writes down behaviors in three groups: physical, online, and emotional or romantic.
- Mark each one “always,” “sometimes,” or “never” counts as cheating, without looking at the other list.
- Compare the lists and talk through every mismatch, especially the “sometimes” items.
- Agree on what you will do when something feels borderline, such as asking first or saying it out loud.
- Revisit the list when your circumstances change.
A psychiatrist quoted in the poll report offers a useful test for the gray areas. Natural curiosity about a past partner, she said, becomes problematic when “they distract from a current committed relationship or hurt a romantic partner’s feelings.” That gives you a question to ask each other: is this affecting us?
Frequently asked questions
Does an emotional connection count as infidelity?
Show answer
There is no universal answer. The 2010 thesis found that many emotional and online behaviors lack a clear consensus. Women classified more of them as infidelity than men did overall, but the item-level differences were small, so each couple has to decide for itself.
Is following an ex on social media cheating?
Show answer
Opinions are split. In the 2017 Deseret News/YouGov poll, 16 percent said it is always cheating and 45 percent said it is sometimes cheating.
Do men and women agree on physical cheating?
Show answer
Largely yes. The 2010 thesis found no differences with regard to physical or sexual infidelity, and in the 2017 poll about three quarters of Americans called sex or kissing someone else always cheating.
Why does the definition change from couple to couple?
Show answer
Views vary with gender, age, faith, sexual orientation and relationship status, according to the poll and the thesis. Because the effects are often small and the online behaviors are new, partners can easily hold different unspoken rules.



